About a year and a half ago, I met and fell in love with a wonderful, handsome, caring free online financial software. Her name was Mint.com.
She was colorful (but only in soothing, Real Simple tones), easy to use, and useful. She downloaded my up to-the-minute account information for my checking accounts, savings accounts, credit card accounts, student loan accounts, and (yes I am that cool) 401K. She suggested tags for all of my transactions (but still let me edit them!), and then tracked how much I'd spent out of each budget category limit I set. She had fun charts and graphs about my spending and was just so pretty. It was all a little reminiscent of Miranda's affair with her Tivo in Season Six of Sex and the City (oh I went there).
Disaster struck when I was preparing to move to England for school. Mint did not want to do long distance. The horrible truth: Mint does not support international accounts! How to keep track of all my accounts on either side of the pond? For a year, I didn't, with less than thrilling results. But this week I took the plunge and tried out some other free sites.
This article at Bankling does a good job of summarizing the three leading online budgeting tools: my beloved Mint, Quicken and Wesabe. It concludes...
Mint: "Robust and graphic-intense, yet still simple enough to set up." Swoon!
Quicken: " Simple and very easy to use."
Wesabe: "The community aspect of Wesabe makes it stand out from Mint.com and Quicken Online, and hopefully they’ll add support for investment accounts soon."
However, the article does not address my specific *international* needs, and misses some other important stuff. First, only Quicken and Wesabe support bank accounts opened outside of the U.S., hence the reason I bid a tearful goodbye to lady Mint.
Second, Wesabe is lacking in major ways. To begin with, the account access is not as streamlined as Mint and Quicken. To set it up you actually guide a Firefox add-on through logging into each of your accounts (even if you have three accounts at one bank i.e. one website and login).
This situation would be manageable except that the credit card accounts only update according to statements, rather than current transactions! This is very unfortunate because your balance will be anywhere from 1 to 30 days behind. Not very helpful for real-time budgeting. You also need to individually tag all of your own transactions and it can't download federal student loans.
Quicken, however, is easy to use, although nowhere near as pretty as Mint. It also accessed all of my various accounts, including my federal student loans. Unfortunately, Quicken's online version is not able to handle multiple currencies (Wesabe's is!). It's just putting everything into dollars, which is extremely frustrating.
In the end it all comes out like this:
Mint
+ Smooth account access
+ 401k and student loan account access
+ Up to the minute budget management
- No international accounts
Quicken
+ Smooth account access
+ 401k and student loan account access
+ Up to the minute budget management
- No multiple currency support
Wesabe
- Clunky account access
- No 401k or student loan account access
- End of the month budget management
+ Multiple currency support
I'm going to give the Wesabe account a chance and hold onto it for a few weeks. But so far I'm not impressed and am pretty sure I'll end up deleting the Wesabe account (one definite plus is the Delete My Membership link is easy to find on the homepage under My Profile) and hanging onto the Quicken. I sadly may need to use Quicken only for British accounts and keep Mint for U.S. accounts. This isn't ideal but at least I'll have a tool for my Oxford budgeting!
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Saturday, September 26, 2009
That Apple Deal
Going back to my comment about Apple's "pretty good deal" on a no-interest-for-12-months Visa card linked purchase...
I want to underline that this is only a good deal if you pay all of your minimum payments on time and pay off the entire cost within 12 months, before the actual interest rate kicks in. I'm personally extremely uptight about always paying off my entire balance because I have a very basic aversion to interest. This comes from an underlying belief that credit cards are evil.
Really though, they are. And this "good deal" is a perfect example of why.
Let's say I want to buy Apple's most affordable laptop with this plan. So it's $999, and the oh-so-helpful website tells me I can get it for "as low as $23 a month." Sweet. This $23 a month is the minimum payment on the Visa credit card I'll have to apply for in order to get this deal. So I apply for the card and buy my new Macbook. I follow the rules like a good credit card customer and pay my minimum payment, $23, every month so I don't lose my no-interest period and get hit with the 27% penalty interest rate (Seriously, read the fine print!). I'm doing great, right? Not quite.
Here's approximately what's going to happen if I take this route...
After paying $23 a month for 12 months, I've only paid off $276 of the $999. That means my balance after the 12 months is $723. Now, the interest kicks in at a mind blowing 20.99% (and that's if they like my credit check. It could be as high as 22.99%). I can keep paying off my minimum balance like a good customer, but each month 21% of the total balance gets added to what I owe.
That means that if I pay $23 dollars in month 13 they'll add $151.83 (21% of $723). Now my balance is $851.83 ($723 - $23 + $151.83). In month 14, if I pay $23 dollars they'll add $178.89 (21% of $851.83). Now my balance is $1007.72 ($851.83 - 23 + 178.89). Impressive. It only took two months (after 12 months of paying my minimum like a good credit card customer) for me to owe more than the cost of the original laptop.
If I keep paying the minimum payment, at month 18 (1.5 years) my balance will be $2,034.87. At month 24 (2 years) it will be $6,152.10 and at month 36 (3 years) it will be $59,627.29 (Yea, I used an Excel spreadsheet. Act like you know!). 3 years after buying my $999 laptop I now owe Visa almost $60,000.00. Seriously. All for being a good, minimum-payment-paying credit card customer (Okay, they'd probably increase that minimum payment somewhere along the way, but you get the picture).
This brings me to my point. It is essential to never ever be a good credit card customer. Credit card companies want you to pay the minimum payment, rather than the balance, because that way you end up owing them tens of thousands of dollars. What you need to do is be the worst possible credit card customer, also known as paying off your entire balance every month.
So again, this "good deal" is only good if you go into it with the mindset that credit cards are evil and protect yourself accordingly by being a bad credit card customer, i.e. paying all minimum payments on time and paying off the entire balance within 12 months.
If I were to take this deal, I'd set up automatic payments on the Visa card through online banking. I'd make the monthly payment equal the total balance divided by 11 (months, just to be safe!). That way I'd always make my minimum payment and pay off the balance a month ahead of time. Victory!
I want to underline that this is only a good deal if you pay all of your minimum payments on time and pay off the entire cost within 12 months, before the actual interest rate kicks in. I'm personally extremely uptight about always paying off my entire balance because I have a very basic aversion to interest. This comes from an underlying belief that credit cards are evil.
Really though, they are. And this "good deal" is a perfect example of why.
Let's say I want to buy Apple's most affordable laptop with this plan. So it's $999, and the oh-so-helpful website tells me I can get it for "as low as $23 a month." Sweet. This $23 a month is the minimum payment on the Visa credit card I'll have to apply for in order to get this deal. So I apply for the card and buy my new Macbook. I follow the rules like a good credit card customer and pay my minimum payment, $23, every month so I don't lose my no-interest period and get hit with the 27% penalty interest rate (Seriously, read the fine print!). I'm doing great, right? Not quite.
Here's approximately what's going to happen if I take this route...
After paying $23 a month for 12 months, I've only paid off $276 of the $999. That means my balance after the 12 months is $723. Now, the interest kicks in at a mind blowing 20.99% (and that's if they like my credit check. It could be as high as 22.99%). I can keep paying off my minimum balance like a good customer, but each month 21% of the total balance gets added to what I owe.
That means that if I pay $23 dollars in month 13 they'll add $151.83 (21% of $723). Now my balance is $851.83 ($723 - $23 + $151.83). In month 14, if I pay $23 dollars they'll add $178.89 (21% of $851.83). Now my balance is $1007.72 ($851.83 - 23 + 178.89). Impressive. It only took two months (after 12 months of paying my minimum like a good credit card customer) for me to owe more than the cost of the original laptop.
If I keep paying the minimum payment, at month 18 (1.5 years) my balance will be $2,034.87. At month 24 (2 years) it will be $6,152.10 and at month 36 (3 years) it will be $59,627.29 (Yea, I used an Excel spreadsheet. Act like you know!). 3 years after buying my $999 laptop I now owe Visa almost $60,000.00. Seriously. All for being a good, minimum-payment-paying credit card customer (Okay, they'd probably increase that minimum payment somewhere along the way, but you get the picture).
This brings me to my point. It is essential to never ever be a good credit card customer. Credit card companies want you to pay the minimum payment, rather than the balance, because that way you end up owing them tens of thousands of dollars. What you need to do is be the worst possible credit card customer, also known as paying off your entire balance every month.
So again, this "good deal" is only good if you go into it with the mindset that credit cards are evil and protect yourself accordingly by being a bad credit card customer, i.e. paying all minimum payments on time and paying off the entire balance within 12 months.
If I were to take this deal, I'd set up automatic payments on the Visa card through online banking. I'd make the monthly payment equal the total balance divided by 11 (months, just to be safe!). That way I'd always make my minimum payment and pay off the balance a month ahead of time. Victory!
Friday, September 25, 2009
Fees and Terms and Penalties Oh My!
So many charges, so little time.
I'm planning ahead for my quick "city break" in Europe with my boyfriend next week. My budget analysis showed that I was losing around 10 pounds each time I took a trip abroad on transaction fees. So I took this opportunity to figure out which of my various cards is best to use abroad. I figured it was also a good idea to summarize the general fee/interest rate situation account for each card while I was at it.
(Actually, this particular activity was inspired by one of my recent crises. When my computer crashed, it looked like I was going to need to buy a new laptop for this year, but I definitely don't have the funds. I was considering carrying a balance on my credit card for the first time ever - gasp! - and wanted to sort out which card was the best bet. In related news, Apple has a pretty good deal going with a 12 month no interest - as long as you make all minimum payments and pay it off in 12 months! - payment plan for its new laptops. It is of course linked to a credit card and has a pretty steep 21 - 23% interest rate after the 12 months. Check it out here but don't miss the fine print.)
Here's what I came up with...
U.S. Checking #1
$8.95 monthly maintenance fee
3% international transaction fee for purchases
1% international transaction fee for ATM withdrawals
$5.00 ATM charge for out-of-network ATMs (Barclays in UK, BNP Paribas in France, Scotiabank in Canada)
U.S. Mastercard
7.90% variable interest rate
25 day grace period
3% international transaction fee
$15 minimum payment
U.S. Visa
12.24% variable interest rate
3% international transaction fee
UK Checking
2.75% international transaction fee for purchases and ATM withdrawals
2% ATM fee for international ATM withdrawals
UK Mastercard
2.75% international transaction fee
5 pound or 2.5% minimum payment
So the long and the short of it is that for ATM withdrawals, my U.S. debit card has the lowest fees at in network ATMs, but I'll still get hit with the crappy exchange rate. But the UK debit card is crazy with the fees! With that one I'd get hit twice, once for the currency conversion and once for the ATM fee.
For purchases, though, the U.K. credit card has the lowest fee. Sadly, I lost the pin (yes, U.K. credit cards require a pin for transactions, crazy I know) about 9 months ago, so unless it's a swipe machine I'll be out of luck. (Don't worry, I asked them to resend the pin and it will be waiting for me when I return to Ox). So coming in at 2nd place for purchases at a 3% transaction fee are the U.S. Checking, the U.S. Mastercard, and the U.S. Visa.
So, I'll be getting myself to a BNP Paribas ATM for any cash withdrawals. Since I only have $200 in my U.S. checking (cringe! and that's thanks the the $75 of Visa rewards points I just cashed in), I'll stick to my U.S. credit cards for emergency purchases. The Mastercard will be my best bet because it has the lower interest rate, in case I end up having to carry a balance for a month or so while I sort out my financial "issues."
Here's hoping my stipend check deposits into my U.K. checking before October 1 so I can pay my rent!
I'm planning ahead for my quick "city break" in Europe with my boyfriend next week. My budget analysis showed that I was losing around 10 pounds each time I took a trip abroad on transaction fees. So I took this opportunity to figure out which of my various cards is best to use abroad. I figured it was also a good idea to summarize the general fee/interest rate situation account for each card while I was at it.
(Actually, this particular activity was inspired by one of my recent crises. When my computer crashed, it looked like I was going to need to buy a new laptop for this year, but I definitely don't have the funds. I was considering carrying a balance on my credit card for the first time ever - gasp! - and wanted to sort out which card was the best bet. In related news, Apple has a pretty good deal going with a 12 month no interest - as long as you make all minimum payments and pay it off in 12 months! - payment plan for its new laptops. It is of course linked to a credit card and has a pretty steep 21 - 23% interest rate after the 12 months. Check it out here but don't miss the fine print.)
Here's what I came up with...
U.S. Checking #1
$8.95 monthly maintenance fee
3% international transaction fee for purchases
1% international transaction fee for ATM withdrawals
$5.00 ATM charge for out-of-network ATMs (Barclays in UK, BNP Paribas in France, Scotiabank in Canada)
U.S. Mastercard
7.90% variable interest rate
25 day grace period
3% international transaction fee
$15 minimum payment
U.S. Visa
12.24% variable interest rate
3% international transaction fee
UK Checking
2.75% international transaction fee for purchases and ATM withdrawals
2% ATM fee for international ATM withdrawals
UK Mastercard
2.75% international transaction fee
5 pound or 2.5% minimum payment
So the long and the short of it is that for ATM withdrawals, my U.S. debit card has the lowest fees at in network ATMs, but I'll still get hit with the crappy exchange rate. But the UK debit card is crazy with the fees! With that one I'd get hit twice, once for the currency conversion and once for the ATM fee.
For purchases, though, the U.K. credit card has the lowest fee. Sadly, I lost the pin (yes, U.K. credit cards require a pin for transactions, crazy I know) about 9 months ago, so unless it's a swipe machine I'll be out of luck. (Don't worry, I asked them to resend the pin and it will be waiting for me when I return to Ox). So coming in at 2nd place for purchases at a 3% transaction fee are the U.S. Checking, the U.S. Mastercard, and the U.S. Visa.
So, I'll be getting myself to a BNP Paribas ATM for any cash withdrawals. Since I only have $200 in my U.S. checking (cringe! and that's thanks the the $75 of Visa rewards points I just cashed in), I'll stick to my U.S. credit cards for emergency purchases. The Mastercard will be my best bet because it has the lower interest rate, in case I end up having to carry a balance for a month or so while I sort out my financial "issues."
Here's hoping my stipend check deposits into my U.K. checking before October 1 so I can pay my rent!
Thursday, September 24, 2009
Paris, Tokyo/Boston, Oxford
Oh, the glamourous, transatlantic, jetsetter life I lead. Dollars, Pounds, Euros, West African Francs... It all gets to be a little much.
In fact, I go to considerable lengths to keep all my currencies separate. As much as possible, I keep dollars in the U.S. and pounds in England. I actually broke this rule when I ended this summer's field research with a bunch of extra Euro travelers checks, and went ahead and cashed them in Boston. But usually I try my best to keep currencies segregated. Here's why...
Moving them around electronically is a no-no because of the charge for "wire transfers." I know, charging me to send myself my own money? Ridiculous.
Also, as I discovered when I got into some tight spots last year and tried to transfer money from my U.S. savings account to my U.K. checking, wire transfers passing through the U.S. take a very long time these days. The nice young man at my local Oxford bank who I turned to on the verge of tears explained that transfers going through the U.S. are some of the slowest around because of post 9/11 money laundering checks/regulations. Awesome.
Last but certainly not least, the financial crisis has wreaked havoc on the exchange rate. To begin with, the dollar is super weak against the pound right now, although not as weak as it was this time last year. That means that moving U.S. dollars into a U.K. account instantly loses me money. Sad face. But grateful face for my luck in having a U.K. scholarship that pays all my fees plus a stipend in pounds. U.S. students who are self financing or using U.S. federal (or private) student loans for their expenses in the U.K. are basically paying 50% more, plus interest. Yikes.
The "exrate" is still moving around a bit, so, stressball that I am I prefer to just keep everything where it is. I actually have a friend who's been managing to make money by moving his cash between accounts at just the right moment, but I'm just not that adventurous. It doesn't help that I'm pretty certain I learned about this particular maneuver in Econ last year, and I'm just not ready to be doing anything out of my Macro textbook.
In fact, I go to considerable lengths to keep all my currencies separate. As much as possible, I keep dollars in the U.S. and pounds in England. I actually broke this rule when I ended this summer's field research with a bunch of extra Euro travelers checks, and went ahead and cashed them in Boston. But usually I try my best to keep currencies segregated. Here's why...
Moving them around electronically is a no-no because of the charge for "wire transfers." I know, charging me to send myself my own money? Ridiculous.
Also, as I discovered when I got into some tight spots last year and tried to transfer money from my U.S. savings account to my U.K. checking, wire transfers passing through the U.S. take a very long time these days. The nice young man at my local Oxford bank who I turned to on the verge of tears explained that transfers going through the U.S. are some of the slowest around because of post 9/11 money laundering checks/regulations. Awesome.
Last but certainly not least, the financial crisis has wreaked havoc on the exchange rate. To begin with, the dollar is super weak against the pound right now, although not as weak as it was this time last year. That means that moving U.S. dollars into a U.K. account instantly loses me money. Sad face. But grateful face for my luck in having a U.K. scholarship that pays all my fees plus a stipend in pounds. U.S. students who are self financing or using U.S. federal (or private) student loans for their expenses in the U.K. are basically paying 50% more, plus interest. Yikes.
The "exrate" is still moving around a bit, so, stressball that I am I prefer to just keep everything where it is. I actually have a friend who's been managing to make money by moving his cash between accounts at just the right moment, but I'm just not that adventurous. It doesn't help that I'm pretty certain I learned about this particular maneuver in Econ last year, and I'm just not ready to be doing anything out of my Macro textbook.
The Mission
As if surviving a last year at Oxford University wasn't enough, I recently discovered that I am in dire financial straits.
This is due in part to 1) highly irresponsible spending over the weekend in NYC; 2) a stipend check that won't arrive for another week; 3) an as yet unresolved insurance claim; and 4) generally being an income-less student. In addition to making it through the various bills, unexpected expenses and travel costs of this academic year, I also need to be saving for that wonderful day when I will return to the working world - and the moving costs, security deposits and down payments that will ensue.
It's enough to make an American girl tremble in her not so stiff upper lip. So instead of doing it on my own, I'll be sharing it with you. Hopefully, we'll make it through together and come out on the other side financially stable, employed, and holding a fancy graduate degree.
This is due in part to 1) highly irresponsible spending over the weekend in NYC; 2) a stipend check that won't arrive for another week; 3) an as yet unresolved insurance claim; and 4) generally being an income-less student. In addition to making it through the various bills, unexpected expenses and travel costs of this academic year, I also need to be saving for that wonderful day when I will return to the working world - and the moving costs, security deposits and down payments that will ensue.
It's enough to make an American girl tremble in her not so stiff upper lip. So instead of doing it on my own, I'll be sharing it with you. Hopefully, we'll make it through together and come out on the other side financially stable, employed, and holding a fancy graduate degree.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
